Why Hasn't My Place/Food Submission Been Published?

The Angry Birds things looks awesome.

I was thinking of adding this one, it’s the oldest swimming pool in Reykjavik and it has this 1930s art deco glamour to it. But I’m not sure if it would pass a test. I think I can sell it, I’ve been there and I think it’s a treat:

1 Like

wrong topic? But yea I think that the pool should make it.

Hey again @CoolCrab. Apologies for the continued confusion. As we’re trying to transition to a more communicative and clear system, we’re rolling out changes including the “not published” and “pending” status disclaimers. For now, those are in place to give users a clear idea of the status of their submission. We’re working on further features that will allow us to communicate more detailed reasons directly with more emails to our users. This email and notification process is in development and should roll out soon. In the meantime, as ever, I encourage you to reach out to our database editors directly at places@atlasobscura.com with any detailed questions or comments about specific place pages.

In regards to the idea you and other users (including @SunnyDandthePurpleSt) have suggested about posting rejected or pending places in the forums for other users to review, I think that’s a fine idea, but I want to set some expectations so that such discussions don’t lead to further confusion or frustration. As it stands, we do not have a direct process for reviewing changes or edits to specific submissions from our forum comments. However, any edits made to the place pages will be reviewed by our editors, and handled as normal. The forum space is here primarily to facilitate discussion between our users, and while our editors and staff are here in the discussions, for the time being, direct communication with them via places@atlasobscura.com and info@atlasobscura.com is still the most efficient way to get more information about your submissions.

Our forum space is still very new and we are actively working on how to make it most useful for our readers. In the future, there may be a more direct link between the submissions process and our forum discussions but for the time being, the database editors are the best source of information regarding our place and food pages.

I hope this helps clear things up, and again I apologize for any confusion you’ve experienced. Thanks again for the continued feedback, and let me know if you have any further questions or concerns.

1 Like

My thread wasnt because i wanted to help ppl get those places published. I just thought itd lead to fun discussion

1 Like

Awesome to hear thanks! To be fair I’m already super happy that you guys work so hard on feedback and site improvement. :slight_smile: Looking forward to the updates.

1 Like

Ah, sorry. Didn’t mean to rope you in unnecessarily.

Also, I did it because it seems like a better way to organize things. You have about 5 or 6 issues on this one thread and it seems better to have different threads so people interested in the mechanics of place acceptance don’t receive notifications about other sightly unrelated topics. It also could liven up the boards as this wouldn’t be the only thread to get traction.

Here is a submission that has been pending review for a long time, and I am curious to see how I could improve it.
It is a Strange sculpture park a few kilometers from Disneyland Paris that not a lot of people, even locals, know about. And it is free…

Enzo Rhode-Hagen

1 Like

Thanks for posting this, the Giacometti Hall is indeed a hidden gem of Zurich. Maybe your entry was not complete, we might add some text.

Hey again Enzo! If you’d like more information regarding a specific submission such as the Dhuys Garden, please send your questions to places@atlasobscura.com and the editors can give you more detailed information about the entry.

If you also see it as a worthy place to add feel free to update or rewrite this entry. Maybe the editors will make a new descision then. Would be great if you also have some pictures to add. When I was submitting this place I did not find any good pictures that would be free to use. And I was only able to snap couple of pics with my phone before I was pointed out that pictures are not allowed (I did not see the sign when entering). My pictures are not the best ones unfortunately.

Allright :slight_smile: Lets wait for some feedback from the editors and I will go and take some pictures! I also don’t have a good camera, but I will see what I can do. May I ask you for the text in this case?

I think that stuff like this would work best in the tweaking thread that I tried to set up. :stuck_out_tongue: I would really want to see one spot where people post their unpublished stuff to fix up.

Hey @TransdisciplinaryExc and @ahvenas. I appreciate your guys’ continued passion and efforts to get this museum added to the Atlas, however, I want to reiterate that posting about specific place entries on the forums will not likely lead to our editors reconsidering their inclusion.

In addition, I cannot stress strongly enough that we do not encourage anyone to disrespect the rules or codes of conduct when visiting any places that they find in the Atlas database or otherwise. This includes museums that do not allow photography. Again, I appreciate your willingness and enthusiasm, but please respect the museum’s rules when visiting.

If you have any further questions about specific submissions, or you want to entreaty our editors to reconsider a place or food entry, please contact them at places@atlasobscura.com.

Hi Erik & co -
I have a handful of places that have been pending for years, and I’m not sure why. They aren’t Salvation Mountain or the Catacombs of Paris or anything, but I think they are worthwhile additions. I also had a few rejected, which really perplexes me when I see something like a Shepard Fairey commissioned Johnny Cash mural get published. I know the rules/standards and have been adding to AO for almost a decade now, but the acceptance/rejection lately feels semi-arbitrary.
Anyways I know how many submissions you all must see a day and really do appreciate your work.

1 Like

Hey @leiris! I really appreciate your patience and I’m very sorry to hear about any frustration or confusion you’re experiencing. Our place page approval process is constantly evolving, but in general, the expectations have remained relatively the same. Our database editors do have final say in the approval of places, but if the approval activity seems more opaque than usual, I apologize. I can’t speak to the decision making behind any specific places pages, but you can always contact the database editors directly at places@atlasobscura.com, with any specific questions about any of your submissions.

In the meantime, I’ll forward your comment on to the database editors, and see if they can take a look. Thanks again for reaching out, and for continuing to be such an active part of the Atlas community. Please do let me know if you have any other questions or comments.

1 Like

We’ve just announced a few of the changes to the Places publishing process that we’re implementing. Many of the changes are based on feedback we’ve received here on the forums, so thanks again for your terrific feedback and contributions!

1 Like

So how long do you generally have to wait for any type of feedback from the database editors? I asked for some general type of what more would you want for an entry and haven’t heard anything from them. Is there any type of were busy but will get back to you reply policy?

1 Like

Hey @sontaron! I’m sorry to hear that you have not received a response to your feedback request. We try to make sure that we respond to all of our user messages within two business days. I’m not sure when you sent your message, but I’ll take a look and see what the situation is. Apologies once again for any frustration, but thank you for reaching out, and let me know if you have any further questions or concerns.

Hi, I was wondering why this place got rejected. It seems like a cool item with a nice backstory to me.